FIFA Assistant Referee Patrick Papala was given a one-year ban for denying Hearts of Oak a genuine goal during their game against Real Tamale United (RTU) at the Accra Sports Stadium during Gameweek 33.
In the last stages of the game, which RTU won 2-1, Papala mistakenly disallowed a goal scored by Yaw Amankwah Baafi, declaring it offside.
Hearts of Oak filed a complaint with the Match Review Committee, arguing that the ruling was incorrect. Following an inquiry, the committee found that Papala had committed a mistake in judgement and suspended him for a year.
The goal should have been permitted since Yaw Amankwah Baafi was not in an offside position, according to the committee’s conclusions.
Foster Bastiours, the match’s centre referee, was also cautioned for failing to accept responsibility when he recognised that Yaw Amankwah was not offside. He was counselled to accept responsibilities in comparable instances if he is certain of his decision’s appropriateness.
Below is the full decision:
SUMMARY OF COMPLAINT
1. a disallowed goal in the 90+ minute scored by player number 7 (Amankwah Baafi).
OBSERVATIONS, FINDINGS AND GROUNDS OF THE DECISION
Per the video watched, it was noticed that player number 7 (Amankwah Baafi) shot into goal at the time of kick the said player was not seen to be in an offside.
REFEREE OFFICIAL RESPONSE
The Assistant referee 1 (Patrick Papala) when contacted on the incident after the video was sent to him, defended his decision to give an offside insisting that the defender made an instinctive reaction and made contact with the ball resulting in the deflecting which sent the ball to the attacker who scored.
The Assistant referee made a lot of images from the video to maintain his decision even though the panel also sent him different angles and images, he insisted that his decision was correct.
DECISION(S)
Per the video watched, the Panel did not see the scorer of the goal in an offside position. The Panel did not also see the instinctive re-action argument of the defender he Patrick Papala eluded to by trying to use as a defence, because the defender saw the ball, had all the time to jump up and swing his head to head or play the ball, which changed direction to an attacker who was not in an Offside position at the time of the kick.
FIFA Assistant Referee 1 Patrick Papala is hereby suspended for one-year (ie., 2023/2024 football season) effective from the date this communication.
The main referee’s phone lines were not going through in all the attempts the Panel made to get in touch with him. However, the panel asked Assistant referee 1 Patrick Papala what they discussed during their consultation. He confirmed that the Referee Foster Bastiours told him that he did not see the incident as offside but he, Patrick Papala insisted that it was an offside therefore, the referee complied and disallowed the goal
Foster Bastiours as the main referee failed to take responsibility when he saw that the goal scorer was not in an offside position and allowed his assistant to dictate to him. He is therefore warned to learn to take responsibility next time when he was sure his decision was correct.
